Do you need an auto insurance quote fast?

Experience Great Rates and Better Service at A Better Choice

A Better Choice Auto Insurance Agency

Your friendly, helpful car insurance agents.

A Better Choice Auto Insurance Agency cuts through the normal nonsense that we've all experienced with the average insurance agency.

There is no need for nonsense or wasting time.

Sounds corny, but we really do care about our clients and their insurance needs.

We are a trusted and respected Colorado Springs auto insurance agency, known for being reliable and friendly. We have been offering great car insurance in Colorado Springs and all over Colorado since 2003.

Enjoy a different and better Colorado Springs auto insurance experience.

Auto Insurance

We offer a wide range of coverages to meet your specific auto insurance needs.

RV Insurance

Enjoy your road trips without the hassle of worrying about RV Coverage

Commercial delivery van for commercial insurance

Commercial Auto Insurance

Commercial automotive insurance customized to keep your business vehicles covered

Boat Insurance

Keep your boat afloat and covered with our affordable coverage for all your boating needs.

Motorcycle Coverage

Stay Safe on the road with our variety of coverage for motorcycles and more!

Renter's Insurance

Keep your personal belongings safe with our wide range of coverage.

Our Colorado Springs Auto Insurance Coverage & Services

We'll help you navigate the roads for the coverage that is right for you!

In just about 10 minutes, you can get quotes for the best rates A Better Choice Auto Insurance has to offer. Get very competitive rate quotes for a wide variety of coverage types of auto insurance in Colorado Springs.

Drive with ease | A Better Choice Auto Insurance

SR22 Coverage

We have been assisting clients with SR22 coverage for twenty years. Get the info you need to get reinstated and back on the road again.

Low Down Payments

Affordable insurance is within your grasp. We can help you find a great that fits your needs.

Insure Multiple Liability Only Vehicles For Less

Only need liability coverage? Select a Broadform Policy and have all of your personal vehicles covered under one affordable plan!

Variable Month Terms

Policies are available in a variety of options including low-down payment policy plans with 1, 3, 6, or 12-month terms.

Full Coverage Options

Buying a new car? Have the coverage you, and your bank, needs to protect your new vehicle.

Bad & Good Credit

No matter what shape your credit is in we can help find an insurance plan that fits your budget and needs.

Discounts & Car Insurance Savings

Keeping customers abreast of opportunities that might mean additional savings are a top priority.

Beyond searching for new opportunities to save, there are initial savings offers that can make a considerable difference in your monthly costs. There are policies available with low down payments and policies based on 1, 6, and 12-month terms. Our desire is to provide affordable insurance to protect you and your family, not just cheap car insurance in Colorado Springs.

You can feel confident that you will find a policy that works best for your circumstances when searching for auto insurance near me!

Be Insured by Top-Rated, Trusted,
A+ Rated Companies

Same great insurance, but for a whole lot less. If they aren't the best then we don't offer them.

Call for a Quote Now

Your BEST choice for auto insurance!

Colorado Springs' Better Insurance Agency

A Better Choice Auto Insurance Agency

4.7

Based on 124 reviews

Joshua Wiebers

03:14 27 Jul 21

I’ve been going here for almost 15 years, John and Rene are always helpful. Lately was in and dealt with Britney and... she was easy to deal with and made everything so simple for my complex problems.read more

Robert Duran

04:59 26 Jul 21

5 out 5 A better choice is really A way Better Choice. I've gotten handfuls of quotes all over that are just... outrageous. The team has always been such a great help and so friendly when I come in for anything. I was sent to them from family and have been insured with them since Ive been driving, 6 years. I recommend to everyone thank you John and team!😁read more

bikes, hikes, outdoor sports

22:22 25 Jun 21

Extremely great customer service! Very nice people who will get you taken care of right and fast!

rick valenzuela

23:36 10 Jun 21

John and Rene are great at getting everyone insured with a perfect policy that fits your every need and budget thanks... again keep up the good work!read more

Deborah Holsten

01:34 21 May 21

They are the nices people i know they help you with any thing

Lynette M

20:33 11 May 21

Love this place .John is always so nice and professional I would highly recommend them.

Katie Tallman

22:10 22 Apr 21

A better choice is exactly what they are! They have an amazing staff that is incredibly helpful, friendly & educated on... everything driving! I have told a few friends to go there and they all end up loving them too!read more

greg white

22:47 30 Mar 21

These guys are great! Easy to work with, very professional, friendly and efficient at what they do. Very glad I found... out about them. It truly is a better choice!read more

Nate Williams

21:50 30 Mar 21

HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE!!!Upon walking in not only is it dead silent, it’s smells weird, (bologna & vacuum smell).... No one says anything like everyone’s to busy to look away from there screen. Eventually I say “how’s it going” and get replied with “Yes!” With a condescending look on her face.... I asked about getting a policy for my new vehicle and she replied “And!”. At this point I just said “have a nice day”. They all smirked and one chick even waved... That and the fact that it’s so quiet in there makes it even more awkward...Like what kind of customer service is this?I’m surprised any one would want to use them for insurance!read more

XStacheX Michael Michaels

20:56 30 Mar 21

This place has poor quality customer service, but helpful at all, sat on the phone for over an hour with no help , left... a number and never got a call back. Had another friend said they tried to make a claim and it was absolute nightmare. Take you money elsewhere!read more

Inda Boof Visuals

19:33 30 Mar 21

Horrible insurance wouldn’t help me after my accident. Way over prices and rude employees. They are not for the people... better off going with State Farm. This insurance sucksread more

Stacey Voss

13:48 20 Mar 21

Great company, staff is wonderful, if they tell you they will get back to you they do!

Heidi Jo Blackshere

02:31 21 Jan 21

I absolutely love this company! I've been with them for years. They are the best insurance company I've ever had! ... I've recommended them to many of my friends and they love them just as much. Customer Service and first impressions mean everything and they scored 100% on both lol! Thank you very much for going above and beyond! Keep up the old school tactics 👏 when you had personal service & small town interest in every customer. Sincerely Heidi Joread more

Edward Somerville

19:49 23 Oct 20

I was pleasantly surprised at how easy and proficient the process was!! Great staff!!

moto Johnny moe

22:18 14 Oct 20

Great people, great service. They always try to find the best for people, and best price. Would highly recommend going... to A Better Choice.read more

R Smith

18:49 02 Oct 20

I just got off the phone after talking to the BEST Insurance agent in Colorado! If you want personable, caring and... professional people looking after your insurance needs, then look no further. John,his wife Renee and Brittany are just "salt of earth" people. Honest and caring people. They take the hassle out of the process. They seem to NEVER forget a face and that's hard in these times. A BIG bonus is that they're DOG people! Thanks ABC Insurance! 😁read more

Patricia Vigil

23:26 27 Sep 20

The friendliest workers in town if you need insurance they sure can help you out

Ben S

19:38 11 Sep 20

I’m a 23 y/o male with a typical lightly rocky record and they have offered the best prices around for 3 years now!

Tyler Gonzalez

19:21 16 Aug 20

Only place I'll Ever Go, Thank You All So Much!

Rgm Gtz

00:55 25 Jul 20

One of the best service I had in car insurance they’re very knowledgeable professionals they will get you an excellent... price for your car insurance thanks Reneeread more

Stellar Spas

22:09 23 Jun 20

Back around 2009, after getting several outrageously high auto insurance quotes (just coming off a suspended license... with an SR22 required), one of the big name insurer agents heard my frustration and recommended A Better Choice. I gave them a call and they came in at less than half of 3 other quotes as I remember. I've been with them ever since. But not blindly. Periodically, I'll spot check to make sure no one else can beat their rates and nothing has changed...every other carrier quotes me far higher. And if/when renewal premium increases with a new policy term, they've usually been able to sniff out a better price and keep it very reasonable.John spent good time on the phone with me last year giving tips for me to manage a parking lot accident that went from my fault to a final decision of mutual fault, causing no increase to my premium.Needless to say, 11 years later, I'm still with them; have recommended them to several friends throughout the years and can affirm they've named their company accurately.read more

Nathalie Gilmore

21:55 29 Apr 20

Renee John Bridget and Michaela are amazing wonderful people. I had some tickets in the past that caused a lot of... insurance companies to raise my full coverage and A Better Insurance helped found me a cheaper rate and on the same day! I am so glad to find you guys! I am happy and happy to drive my new used car 😊😊😊read more

Brandon

15:15 11 Mar 20

great people awsome insurance coverage always take really good care of there people.

john barly

02:01 07 Mar 20

This was one of the best insurance experiences I have ever had! Friendly people always very helpful and professional. I... would and will reccomend A Better Choice To Anyone.read more

Travis Pacheco

02:57 15 Feb 20

They are awesome people who go out of their way to get you the best prices possible! I recommend them to everyone

Trina Vaughan

21:10 12 Feb 20

A better choice has taken great care of us for years. I highly recommend them.

Clone Trapper TV

23:06 31 Jan 20

Me and my wife really love this place our agents always get us the best deals we will continue to bring them our... business #aBetterChoiceInsurance 🤝read more

Turbo Tyler

23:14 13 Jan 20

A+ insurance company who really strives to help you find the best policy.They worked very had for us.

Next Reviews

Get a personalized quote today.

There are many coverage options and limits involved in acquiring an accurate insurance quote. At A Better Choice Insurance Agency we highly recommend you have an experienced insurance agent assist you in getting the right coverage you need.

Simply call us at 719-667-1301, most quotes take less than 15 minutes to complete.

Are you a Night Owl?

No matter what time of day, we can help you get the coverage you need. Get your LIABILITY ONLY quote from our partner, Dairyland, any time of the day -- or night.

Get a Liability Only Quote ⯈

Do you need an auto insurance quote fast?

Experience Great Rates and Better Service at A Better Choice

A Better Choice Auto Insurance Agency

Your friendly, helpful car insurance agents.

Auto Insurance

RV Insurance

Commercial Auto Insurance

Boat Insurance

Motorcycle Coverage

Renter's Insurance

Our Colorado Springs Auto Insurance Coverage & Services

SR22 Coverage

Low Down Payments

Insure Multiple Liability Only Vehicles For Less

Variable Month Terms

Full Coverage Options

Bad & Good Credit

Discounts & Car Insurance Savings

Colorado Springs' Better Insurance Agency

Get a personalized quote today.

Are you a Night Owl?

Request Quote